Learning Activity 4.3
For this activity, I chose to focus on Sendjaya and Sarros’ (2002) article Servant leadership: Its origin, development, and application in organizations.
- Does the review include relevant literature?
Rating: 3/3
Yes, the article includes a variety of different sources. The article cites over 50 sources on the topic of servant leadership. - Does the review examine sources that are recent and of high quality?
Rating: 3/3
Given the article was published in 2002, the sources that they used were recent at that time. The articles that the authors cited were all published in reputable, peer-reviewed journals or by reliable publishing houses. - Is the literature review documented properly?
Rating: 3/3
Yes, the article is properly cited using APA style. - Is the literature thoughtfully synthesized?
Rating: 3/3
Yes, the authors used clear and appropriate titles for each section. The article is laid out well and flows nicely from one section to the next.
- Is the literature critically examined?
Rating: 1/3
The authors do not mention any limitations or weaknesses of the literature except that there is a need for empirical data in future research in this area. No recommendations for future research are made.
- Does the study have a strong foundation in the literature?
Rating: 3/3
Yes, the authors draw strong connections between the literature and the article. - Does the literature fit the study’s overall approach?
Rating: 3/3
Since the article is a theoretical discussion, the literature research is the main content of the article. The literature is appropriate and on topic.
Original assignment post found here.