- What factors do you think shape your decision-making process as a leader?
- I believe that the most influential factors in my decision-making process are my own personal values, policies that are in place, past experiences, and the knowledge and advice that I seek from people that are experienced and that I trust. When faced with decision making I first look to policy to see what I am professionally obligated to do. Then, I often make lists of pros and cons of the decisions I could make. These lists include the effects the decision will have on other people and whether or not it is true to my values and beliefs. When I am faced with difficult decisions, I often seek advice from people whom I trust. These people include family members, colleagues whom I know have been faced with similar decisions, and my administration team. All of these people are experienced and have valuable advice to offer.
- Do you agree or disagree with the proposition made in the course notes (by the authors) that one’s worldview influences the types of questions that you ask, and the processes that you use to find the answers to your questions?
- I agree with the proposition that is made in the course notes that one’s worldview influences the types of questions that a person will ask. I experience this everyday in my profession. Young children ask questions based on their personal experiences and based on things that connect to their worldviews. They ask questions based on things that they have seen or experienced and that they want to know more about. People try to make sense of new information by connecting it to their own worldview to see how it fits in with their view.
- Close with one question that invites further comment and discussion.
- Can our own worldview’s create a personal bias that would skew our research results? Would our reading, analyzing and research be stronger if our personal worldview’s were not a factor?
Develop a passion for learning. If you do, you will never cease to grow. -Anthony J. D'Angelo. A TWU Digital Learning Commons site
An informative post, Sadie. I also often find myself making pro and cons lists when making decisions. I find it a useful visual tool and I also observe how easy I find it filling in each column. I like the idea of creating multiple lists based upon outcomes. I haven’t done it like that before I will have to give it a go.
In response to your question. I think it very much depends on the type of research you are undertaking. If it is more literature review based then I think worldview could play a part in how and where you process your information. However, if it is scientific or data driven I’m not sure worldview could have as much impact.
I remember an old lecturer telling me when writing my bachelor’s research paper that my opinion counts for nothing. I remember feeling a bit taken aback at the time almost offended. However, I now understand what she meant in terms of finding a variety of sources, and opinions offering different viewpoints enhances any paper. I think the key to avoiding worldview influencing too much is ensuring well-balanced arguments.
Great questions Sadie!
I think if left unchecked (i.e. not peer reviewed) then yes researchers could potentially skew their own research results to suit their own needs whether that be publicity, financial gains, or promotion. There are systems in place to make sure bias doesn’t happen, but the systems are not always perfect.
Dr. Strong